Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy
By Sr. Rose Pacatte, F.S.P.
Spy master John La Carre’ wrote seven novels featuring
George Smiley the head of British intelligence agency MI6, the “Circus”, during
the Cold War. The final three novels put Karla, head of Moscow’s spy ring, in
opposition to Smiley. If director Tomas Alfredson’s cinematic interpretation of
“Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy” is successful perhaps the other two, “The Honorable
Schoolboy: and “Smiley’s People” will follow.
(Television viewers may recall Alec Guinness in the BBC version of this
Gary Oldman plays Smiley who is forced into retirement when
a British agent’s plan to bring in a key contact in Budapest ends in disaster.
Word is out that there is a mole in the Circus and when the agents fail to
discover him, Smiley is brought back to work his spy magic and reveal the
The inspiration for La Carre’s stories is based on “The
Cambridge Five”, British citizens who spied for Moscow during the 1950s and
I have never found La Carre’ spy stories particularly easy
to read, so I have not read the Smiley series. I seem to always get lost in his
convoluted plots. “Tinker Tailor Soldier
Spy” as a film, however, is a dark thriller told through flashbacks and flash
forwards that held my attention all the way through. Spying was a more simple craft in the days
when there were only two super powers trying to outwit the other, each with a
finger on atomic weapons. There is a twist in the film that adds an emotional
dimension that reflects the Cambridge connection again.
Ultimately the theme is about patriotism, loyalty, and
betrayal on the level of the individual and one’s country, and between
countries with the same goals. It is very well acted and worthy of seeing for
the performances and quality of direction if nothing else. I think the appeal
is to fans of La Carre’ and anyone who is nostalgic for the old days of the
Cold War genre in literature and film. It was an era that gave rise to the
global situation today that is far more volatile and dangerous and solutions
complicated by unbridled globalization that marginalizes the poor and makes
But here’s the problem with “Tinker Tailor Soldier
Spy” as a movie. If you load a film with a cast made up of the usual suspects,
that is, the most recognizable actors in British cinema today, you will know
within the first ten minutes or less who the bad guy is – just by process of
elimination. It is still an okay movie;
it’s just that filmmakers have to realize that audiences are a lot smarter than
they think we are. The Cold War is pretty old hat, though a good mystery always
Thank you for your comments. Editors will review all posts before they are visible on the website.
blog comments powered by