Skip Navigation Links
Catholic News
Special Reports
Social Media
Google Plus
RSS Feeds

About   |   Subscribe   |   Order Print Copies   |   Archive


Praydreaming: Key to Discernment
By: Mark E. Thibodeaux, S.J.

Each issue carries an imprimatur from the Archdiocese of Cincinnati. Reprinting prohibited
We Christians don’t just decide things, we discern them. That is, we do our best to figure out what God is calling us to in every situation. We do our best to say yes to that divine invitation. But how do we discern God’s will for us? That’s the tricky part.

There are a number of approaches to discernment in the Catholic tradition. The one I know the best comes from St. Ignatius of Loyola, founder of the Jesuits, who lived in Europe during the 16th century. His insights are so rich and abundant that hundreds of books have been written about his life and work.

It is impossible to set down very many of the insights in an Update. But in the area of discernment, one insight in particular seems to be the key for understanding his perspective. His insight was this: “Good discernment consists of prayerfully pondering the great desires that well up in my daydreams.”

Great desires

Are desires good or bad? Many spiritual writers of Ignatius’ day spoke of desires as obstacles to God’s will. One solution was to suppress one’s desires—to eliminate them whenever possible. Ignatius, on the other hand, held the radical notion that God dwells in the desires of a good person.

Not only are desires not evil, but they are one of God’s primary instruments of communicating his will to his children. God enflames the heart with holy desires, and with attraction toward a life of greater divine praise and service. Ignatius did not seek to squash desires, but rather sought to tap into the deepest desires of the heart, trusting that it is God who has placed them there.

Desires, of course, play a role in my sinful choices, too. But Ignatius would define sin as disordered desire. The problem is not that I have desires, but that they are disordered within me. That is why I must begin this entire process by tapping into the greatest, most universal desire among humans: to praise, reverence and serve God.

A teenager may want badly to have sexual relations with a girlfriend or boyfriend. Spouses may become sexually attracted to people outside of their marriage. Are these evil desires? No, they are merely disordered desires. Why do any of these people want intimate sexual relations? Because each craves oneness with another—each is created by God, for the experience of unity.

Another example: An older woman may desire to tell off her husband. In what ways might the roots of this desire be holy? Perhaps she has been too passive all these years. Perhaps she only now loves herself and values herself enough to stick up for what she believes is right. Perhaps she desires to reverence God’s creation (her very self) by asserting herself. These deeper desires are not evil; they are, in fact, holy. They come from God. If she can focus on these great desires beneath the desire to tell her husband off, then she will not sin.

We fall into sin when we are ignorant of the desires beneath the desires. Consider this way of understanding personal sin: We sin, not because we are in touch with our desires but precisely because we are not in touch with them! This is one of Ignatius’ most profound insights.


How, then, do I tap into these great desires? I daydream, that’s how! I fantasize about great and beautiful futures. I let God dream in me and I sit in silent awe and wonder as these holy dreams come to life before the eyes and ears of my soul. Now that’s a different approach to prayer than most of us know. But that’s what St. Ignatius taught.

If I have to choose among several different options, I might start with one option, and ask God to show me the marvelous things he could do with this possibility. I think crazy thoughts and mull over preposterous proposals. I have galactic visions of new worlds of possibilities opening up merely by saying yes to God’s invitation to that option.

I then start all over again and dream about a second option, a third one and so on.

Let’s look at an example. Say I’m a manager who has just been given an offer to relocate to a faraway city and join a more prestigious company. My immediate inclination might be to feel frightened of all the threatening unknowns: Will my family be happy in this new place? Will I like my new bosses? Will I find affordable housing? Will I be burning bridges with my current firm? All of these are reasonable concerns and will have to be considered later.

St. Ignatius would argue that these negative considerations are not the proper starting point for discernment. Instead, he said, start with dreams and desires.

I might begin by asking the big questions: “What is my purpose in life?” Of course, the answer Catholics learned as children applies: To praise, reverence and serve God.

I might then ask, “How am I uniquely called to do this?” First, as a spouse and parent. Second, as a manager. Then, “In my current roles, what are my dreams for my family?” First, that we be healthy and safe. Second, that we be a family bonded with love and care for one another. Third, that our children might be not merely well-educated, but also well-formed in Church and school.

Then I ponder, “What are my dreams for my career?” That I might serve God and society through my profession. That I be honest, professional and fair-minded. That I might seek justice above all.

Now, I begin to daydream—or better—to praydream! I ask myself, “How might I make these goals for my family and my job come to life, remaining here in my current job?” (Option A). I dream great dreams of all that could happen in the life of our family and work if I continue in my current job or place.

Then I dream Option B: How might I make these goals come to life moving to the new job and city? To prayerfully explore my options, I praydream all of the possibilities.

Note the difference between the way most people normally decide and this radical way of discerning that St. Ignatius is proposing. Most lead with the wrong foot: They allow the tools of the false spirit to drive the bus: fear and anxiety (“What will happen?”), ambition (“Here’s my chance to rise!”), pride (“It’s a more prestigious employer”), jealousy (“Finally, I’ll leave my co-workers in the dust!”) and so on. There will be time enough to deal with these negative realities. But for now, I allow my great desires to drive the bus. I imagine the greatest potentialities—the best-case scenarios—for each option. For now, I dream of glorious possibilities.

Pondering the praydreams

As I allow myself to dream crazy dreams, I then begin to ponder their meaning. As I praydream the possibilities of living out my great desires in each option, I try to note the stirrings in my heart. I ask myself:

After the initial excitement of new possibilities, or after the initial fear of potential problems, which dreams leave me in consolation? That is:

• Which of these dreams leave me filled with holy and wholesome desires?
• Which leave me with a sense of closeness to God?
• Which leave me filled with faith? With hope? With love?
• Which make me want to go out and share them with the people I love? With my mentors and friends?
• Which leave me with a deep-down peace and tranquility? With a sense of rightness? With a fits-like-a-glove sort of feeling?

Then I discern, Which dreams leave me in desolation? That is:

• Which leave me without faith? Without hope? Without love?
• Which leave me with a sense of distance from God?
• Which leave me disquiet and agitated?
• Which leave me with no passion and zeal? With a sense of boredom and tepidity? With no energy? Feeling deflated?
• Which fill me with deep-down anxiety and fear?
• Which are the dreams I’m not very excited to talk about with my mentors or friends? Which are the ones that I avoid mentioning to them?

As I dream these praydreams, I pay particular attention to the fluctuating moments of peace vs. disquiet, and of impassioned energy vs. deflatedness.

Paid Advertisement
Ads contrary to Catholic teachings should be reported to our webmaster. Include ad link.

Peace vs. disquiet

Ignatius says that when a well-intentioned, prayerful person is in sync with God, God’s will comes “sweetly, lightly, gently, as a drop of water that enters a sponge.” This inner peace—even for a tough decision—is one of the most important telltale signs of God’s will.

When I ponder my praydreams, which of the options leave me feeling this way? Which leave me with a sense of deep-down peace? Note that I am searching for the deep-down peace, as opposed to simply feeling comfortable with the option.

It may well be that God’s will lies in the most frightening option (for example, leaving a comfortable job in order to enter religious life, or firing an unfit employee instead of ignoring the problem or choosing some unpopular course of action).

I may therefore feel fearful when I praydream this scenario, and yet deeper down, there is a sense in me that this is the proper way to go and that the Lord’s abiding presence will sustain me through the unpleasant fallout. It is this deeper peace that I am looking out for.

I am also looking out for its opposite—for deep-down agitation. Again, one particular option may look good on paper and make me feel comfortable on the surface of my emotions. This “easy option” may smooth things over, avoid conflict or avoid unpleasant or awkward situations (for example, upholding the status quo, remaining in current status, not making waves at the office, making only complimentary remarks).

Despite the fact that this option is clearly the path of least resistance, deeper down there is agitation within me. There is something that isn’t quite settled in my spirit as I imagine myself moving forward in this direction. This negative indicator of sensing agitation is as important as the positive indicator of sensing deep-down peace.

Another example might help: A proud mom is helping her 18-year-old son to choose a college to attend. It has come down to the local state college just down the road from where they live and a much larger school on the other side of the country. Her son takes his mom’s advice very seriously and wants to know what she thinks. What should she advise?

When she praydreams about her son at the local college, she feels warmth and comfort. Her son could come over often for meals and Sunday football with his brothers. If anything bad were to happen, she and his dad would be only minutes away. They could continue to have long conversations in the kitchen while preparing for supper. But deeper down, she senses a bit of agitation in herself—something not quite right about the feel of these praydreams.

When she praydreams about her son going to college on the West Coast, she feels frightened and alarmed. None of her children have ever lived far away. How would we get to him if he needs us? How often would he come home? How many important family events will he miss because it is simply too expensive and time-consuming to get him back for them? She feels quite uncomfortable with this option. But deeper down she is shocked to find a sense of peace within herself.

She knows that her son is a good and responsible young man and that he is quite capable of taking care of himself. She would miss him terribly, but she knows that this might well be his moment for the great adventure of starting out anew. She herself had the same experience years ago and wouldn’t give it up for all the tea in China.

Only now, after coming to peace with the less comfortable but more peace-filled option, can she begin to help her son make this all-important decision.

Impassioned energy vs. deflatedness

This same discernment was an important part of my own journey toward the priesthood, and, more recently, toward a request to consider four options that led to my assignment as novice director for my province of Jesuits.

When I praydreamed the option I thought I most wanted, I was surprised by what I felt and didn’t feel. I felt less energy. I could envision myself doing the work and even enjoying it, but I didn’t feel “the baby leap in my womb for joy,” as Elizabeth described her recognition of God’s presence in her pregnant cousin, Mary.

This leaping prenatal John the Baptist is a good metaphor of the kind of reaction your soul has when coming in contact with the presence of the Lord in some pregnant future possibility. Your soul leaps with joy and excitement! It describes the crackle of electricity that I felt when I prayed over some of the other possibilities.

The moment you just know

Often, after many hours of prayerful deliberation, there will be a moment when you will just know. It will feel not as though you are making a decision but, rather, as though you are acknowledging a decision that has already been agreed upon by God and your heart.

I’ll recognize this auspicious moment by the way one option over the others leads to praydreams. Maybe those praydreams aren’t idealistic, comfortable or beautiful. But somehow they are realistic and right, more peaceful and charged with energy. These dreams will fit like a glove.

All the other options—though perhaps more beautiful, more comfortable or more safe—will drift farther from my soul’s watchful eye and will begin to fade into the horizon.

The final step

Once we feel that we have reached a point of decision, Ignatius suggests we place that decision before God and await his confirmation. How will this confirmation come? In the same way that our initial discernment came. It will be through pondering the stirrings of our heart as we begin to take the first tentative steps toward our new option.

Perhaps the decision will be unpopular or uncomfortable, but deeper down, is there peace? Is your heart charged with God’s energy? If so, then you can move forward with the decision, knowing that you have done all that you could to discern God’s desires. You’ve pondered the desires he seems to have placed in your dreams.

Deciding is not an easy task. Discerning God’s will is even more challenging! But St. Ignatius assures me that God has placed his desire deep within the desires of my own heart. Praydreaming allows me to ponder those deep desires and to discover and say yes to God’s grace-filled path for my life.

Mark E. Thibodeaux, S.J., is a spiritual director, retreat director, high school teacher and Jesuit priest. He holds a Master of Divinity from Weston Jesuit School of Theology in Cambridge, Massachusetts. He is the author of Armchair Mystic: Easing Into Contemplative Prayer and God, I Have Issues (St. Anthony Messenger Press).

NEXT: Darwin and Christianity (by Paula Gonzalez, S.C., Ph.D.)

I want to order print copies of this issue of Catholic Update.
Bulk discounts available!

I want to get digital access to this issue of Catholic Update.

I want to order a 12-month bulk subscription to hand out in my parish or classroom.

I want to purchase access to the library of Catholic Update issues available digitally.

Bernadette Soubirous: Bernadette Soubirous was born in 1844, the first child of an extremely poor miller in the town of Lourdes in southern France. The family was living in the basement of a dilapidated building when on February 11,1858, the Blessed Virgin Mary appeared to Bernadette in a cave above the banks of the Gave River near Lourdes. Bernadette, 14 years old, was known as a virtuous girl though a dull student who had not even made her first Holy Communion. In poor health, she had suffered from asthma from an early age. 
<p>There were 18 appearances in all, the final one occurring on the feast of Our Lady of Mt. Carmel, July 16. Although Bernadette's initial reports provoked skepticism, her daily visions of "the Lady" brought great crowds of the curious. The Lady, Bernadette explained, had instructed her to have a chapel built on the spot of the visions. There the people were to come to wash in and drink of the water of the spring that had welled up from the very spot where Bernadette had been instructed to dig. </p><p>According to Bernadette, the Lady of her visions was a girl of 16 or 17 who wore a white robe with a blue sash. Yellow roses covered her feet, a large rosary was on her right arm. In the vision on March 25 she told Bernadette, "I am the Immaculate Conception." It was only when the words were explained to her that Bernadette came to realize who the Lady was. </p><p>Few visions have ever undergone the scrutiny that these appearances of the Immaculate Virgin were subject to. Lourdes became one of the most popular Marian shrines in the world, attracting millions of visitors. Miracles were reported at the shrine and in the waters of the spring. After thorough investigation Church authorities confirmed the authenticity of the apparitions in 1862. </p><p>During her life Bernadette suffered much. She was hounded by the public as well as by civic officials until at last she was protected in a convent of nuns. Five years later she petitioned to enter the Sisters of Notre Dame. After a period of illness she was able to make the journey from Lourdes and enter the novitiate. But within four months of her arrival she was given the last rites of the Church and allowed to profess her vows. She recovered enough to become infirmarian and then sacristan, but chronic health problems persisted. She died on April 16, 1879, at the age of 35. </p><p>She was canonized in 1933.</p> American Catholic Blog In humility, a woman ultimately forgets 
herself; forgets both her shortcomings and accomplishments equally and 
strives to remain empty of self to make room for Jesus, just as Mary 

Pope Francis!

Why did the pope choose the name Francis? Find out in this new book by Gina Loehr.

The Seven Last Words

By focusing on God's love for humanity expressed in the gift of Jesus, The Last Words of Jesus serves as a rich source of meditation throughout the year.

Visiting Mary
In this book Cragon captures the experience of visiting these shrines, giving us a personal glimpse into each place.
John Paul II

Here is a book to be read and treasured as we witness the recognition given John Paul II as a saint for our times.

The Surprising Pope

Get new insight into this humble and gentle man—Pope John XXIII--who ushered in the Church's massive changes of Vatican II.

Wednesday of Holy Week
Today join Catholics around the world in offering prayers for our Pope Emeritus on his 87th birthday.
Tuesday of Holy Week
Today keep in prayer all the priests and ministers throughout the world who will preside at Holy Week services.
Monday of Holy Week
Holy Week reminds us of the price Jesus paid for our salvation. Take time for prayer at home and at church.
Palm Sunday
Holy Week services and prayers invite us to follow Jesus into Jerusalem, experiencing the events of his passion and death.
Praying for You
As they grow closer to the Easter sacraments, your parish’s RCIA candidates welcome your prayers.

Come find us at: Facebook | St. Anthony Messenger magazine Twitter | American Catholic YouTube | American Catholic